1. Replika Ai
4.6/5 · from $5.83/monthCheaperRated higher
Best long-term memory I've tested in a companion app, especially on higher tiers.
- Paid plans start at $5.83 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.6 in our testing against 3.8
Secrets AI Alternatives: 8 Sites Like Secrets AI in 2026
Secrets AI scores 3.8 out of 5 in our testing, so this is not a list of replacements for something broken. It is a list for the specific reasons people go looking elsewhere, and each option below is here because it does one of those things better.
Why people look for a Secrets AI alternative
These are the drawbacks we recorded in our own Secrets AI review, and they are the reasons that send people to the options below.
- The struck-through $39.99 and $79.99 are each a penny over exactly double what the monthly plans actually charge, so the real annual savings are 54.15% and 33.32%
- The cheapest paid way in has gone from $5.99 to $19.99 a month, 3.34 times more, with Lite, Plus and both Moments bonuses deleted
- The BEST VALUE badge sits on Ultimate, which is worse per Moment on both cycles (2.001 times the price for 1.875 times the Moments)
- No published Moments rate card anywhere, on the panel or in any of the fifteen legal documents
- The free plan includes zero Moments, so media is behind a purchase from the first minute
- They own every generated image, video, voice clip and companion reply, and license it back to you for personal non-commercial use only
- Cancelling closes your account at the end of the billing period and takes your companions and chat history with it, which the card's cancel-anytime line never mentions
Secrets AI alternatives compared
| App | Our score | From | Better than Secrets AI at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secrets AI (the one you know) | 3.8 | $19.99 | — |
| Replika Ai | 4.6 | $5.83 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| HeyGF AI | 4.5 | $9.99 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| Candy AI | 4.4 | — | More characters, Rated higher |
| Nomi Ai | 4.4 | $15.99 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| Character Ai | 4.3 | $7.92 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| Kindroid | 4.3 | $13.99 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| Anima Ai | 4.2 | $3.33 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
| Nectar Ai | 4.2 | $12.99 | Cheaper, Rated higher |
The alternatives in detail
2. HeyGF AI
4.5/5 · from $9.99/monthCheaperRated higher
141 handcrafted, realistic characters with backstories, aged 18 to 67, from about 50 countries, with accents to match.
- Paid plans start at $9.99 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.5 in our testing against 3.8
3. Candy AI
4.4/5More charactersRated higher
The crossed-out €13.99 price is real: it's what the monthly plan renews at, so the discount math checks out..
- A larger character library than Secrets AI offers
- Scores 4.4 in our testing against 3.8
4. Nomi Ai
4.4/5 · from $15.99/monthCheaperRated higher
Long term memory is the best in this catalogue, scored 4.8 out of 5 in the longest hands-on test and confirmed by every other hands-on report.
- Paid plans start at $15.99 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.4 in our testing against 3.8
5. Character Ai
4.3/5 · from $7.92/monthCheaperRated higher
Actually unlimited free messaging, no credits or daily caps to babysit.
- Paid plans start at $7.92 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.3 in our testing against 3.8
6. Kindroid
4.3/5 · from $13.99/monthCheaperRated higher
47-parameter character builder that's genuinely the deepest I've used in this category, and it's not marketing fluff, the output actually reflects what you set.
- Paid plans start at $13.99 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.3 in our testing against 3.8
7. Anima Ai
4.2/5 · from $3.33/monthCheaperRated higher
Annual plan works out to $3.33/mo, which is stupidly cheap for what you get.
- Paid plans start at $3.33 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.2 in our testing against 3.8
8. Nectar Ai
4.2/5 · from $12.99/monthCheaperRated higher
One clear plan at $4.99 a month billed $59.99 for the year, no tier maze.
- Paid plans start at $12.99 against Secrets AI's $19.99
- Scores 4.2 in our testing against 3.8
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Secrets AI alternative?
It depends on what pushed you away from Secrets AI. If it was the cost, the cheapest option here is Anima Ai at $3.33 a month. If it was the limited character selection, the apps flagged as having a larger library are the ones to look at first.
Are there free sites like Secrets AI?
Every app on this page has a free tier, and each review says exactly where that free tier stops: a daily message cap, a token bundle that runs out, or unlimited text with images locked behind payment.
Is Secrets AI still worth using?
For most people yes, which is why it scores well in our testing. This page exists for the cases where it does not fit: if you want a bigger character roster or cheaper media generation, the options below do those specific things better.
Still deciding? Our full Secrets AI review covers what it does well, and the overall ranking puts all 9 of these apps side by side.